Environmental enforcement takes many forms and involves many different players. This course, taught by Sidley Austin partner David Buente and associate Benjamin Tannen, will introduce the concept of “cooperative federalism” inherent in most federal environmental laws - which means that federal, state, and local agencies all can be involved in environmental enforcement. The program will provide an overview of the enforcement process, from the role that various agencies play to the methods these enforcers use to gather compliance information in anticipation of enforcement. It will then provide an in-depth look at administrative, civil, and criminal enforcement, illuminating the differences between these types of enforcement through the use of a Clean Water Act hypothetical.
The program also looks at enforcement by private parties, a unique method of enforcement available under many federal environmental statutes known as the citizen suit. Additionally, it will address hot topics in environmental enforcement, such as the 2015 Yates memorandum on
Provide an overview of environmental enforcement, including the relevant agencies, statutes, and types of relief available
Understand the differences between administrative, civil, and criminal environmental enforcement
Convey the role that environmental non-governmental organizations (NGOs) play in environmental enforcement through citizen suits
DAVID BUENTE, co-leader of Sidley’s Environmental group, represents clients in complex environmental litigation and rulemaking matters, with an emphasis on Clean Air Act (CAA), Clean Water Act, CERCLA (Superfund) and RCRA, environmental criminal and toxic tort litigation. Building upon his 15 years as an environmental prosecutor, including at the Department of Justice (DOJ) where he served as Chief, Environmental Enforcement Section, corporations—including American Electric Power, CSX, Duke Energy, Exxon Mobil, General Electric, Ford Motors, Honeywell, Norfolk Southern, Tyson Foods and Verizon —turn to David for representation in complex federal environmental enforcement matters with DOJ and EPA and in defending toxic tort claims by states and private parties.
David's recent experience includes:
A recognized leader in his field, David has been named the Best Lawyers’ 2015 Washington, D.C. Environmental Law “Lawyer of the Year,” an accolade awarded to only a single lawyer in each practice area and geographic region; he also received this recognition in 2012–2014. He has been named by Chambers USA as one of the nation’s Leading Lawyers since 2006. In the 2015 edition of Chambers, David is praised as “extremely well grounded in the substance of a matter, and is somebody you can turn to in a situation as he keeps his head and keeps his focus.” The Legal 500 lists David as a leading lawyer in the product liability and mass tort defense: toxic tort category. The 2015 edition of Chambers includes David in its top-tier of Washington, D.C.’s environmental lawyers, noting that “According to his peers, in the area of civil and criminal enforcement, ‘no one has as much knowledge of the issues and history of those issues as’ David Buente.” Chambers also includes David in its nationwide list of top Product Liability & Mass Torts lawyers, acknowledging that he “is highly regarded throughout the market, earning praise as a fantastic litigator.”
David also regularly is named in other surveys of private sector lawyers, including: Who’s Who Legal USA: Environment, PLC: Which Lawyer? and The Legal 500 US. In 2016, Who’s Who Legal named David the 2016 Environmental Lawyer of the Year. David is an elected member of the American College of Environmental Lawyers and of the National Trial Lawyers “Top 100.”
Benjamin Tannen is a senior staff attorney in Consolidated Edison Company of New York, Inc.’s Law Department’s environmental group. At Con Edison, Ben works on issues related to remediation and environmental compliance under federal, New York State, and New York City environmental laws, including air requirements. Previously, Ben worked as an associate in Sidley Austin LLP’s environmental group in its Washington, DC and then New York, NY offices. At Sidley, Ben represented clients in regulatory environmental matters and in civil and criminal environmental enforcement, including matters involving the Clean Air Act’s New Source Review and Section 111 programs. Ben is a member of the steering committee of the Environmental Law Institute’s Emerging Leaders Initiative, a vice chair of the American Bar Association’s Environmental Enforcement and Crimes Committee, and a member of the New York City Bar Association’s Environmental Law Committee.
Excellent! Very informative.
Interesting and informative. The speakers provided a lot of information and examples.
A lot of material to cover! Good overview and practice tips.
Very interesting program Second speaker very good
I found this information very useful.
Good overview, especially regarding law and procedures at the federal level of environmental law enforcement.
Good hypothetical case to illustrate statutes
Well organized presentation -- good hypothetical.
Good discussion. Helpful.
Interesting area of the law.
good disussion of the key Federal Environmental law provissions a corporate attorney needs to know to better serve their employer.
Presenters were knowledgeable and interesting. Use of fact patterns was very helpful in understanding the materials presented.
This was a good effort at making a complex situation understandable.
I thought the presenters did an excellent job and the written content was outstanding--better than the content of most CLEs I have taken.
very good throughout
Use of the hypothetical is an effective tool for teaching.
good example case
Very basic information--would love to see a more advanced session on one of the major statutes--CWA, CAA, RCAR.
Excellent. These guys did not waste any time with fluff. They filled the hour solidly. Good job
The two faculty are very knowledgeable and present the subject in a very easy to digest format with their slides and presentation. I would highly recommend this course.