Virginia Landlord-Tenant Disputes: The Intersection of the Lease, the Laws, and the Landlord-Tenant Relationship

(349 Ratings)

Produced on: September 25, 2017

Course Format On Demand

Taught by


Course Description

Time 60 minutes
Difficulty Intermediate
The landlord-tenant relationship is a complex one which is often the subject of disputes and litigation. When such problems arise, an assessment of the rights and obligations of the parties—and, ultimately, the solutions to these problems—must take into consideration the requirements established through the governing lease, all applicable landlord-tenant statutes, and controlling case law. In addition, in order to fully assess the best going forward strategies, options and next steps, lawyers must have a clear understanding not only of these requirements, but of the facts surrounding the particular issues in dispute as well as the procedures for addressing these issues in the courts. Moreover, depending on the type of dispute, the ultimate resolution may also be affected by related laws pertaining to real estate, to creditor’s rights, and to bankruptcy.  

John Ivins, a partner with the law firm of Hirschler Fleischer who has practiced in this area for more than 20 years, will explore the complexities of handling cases in this area, addressing not only the legal requirements, but also business and client considerations as well as possible approaches for solving landlord-tenant disputes whether through litigation or otherwise.  

Learning Objectives:
  1. Identify the landlord and tenant’s rights, duties and obligations established by the lease, applicable statutes and controlling case law
  2. Develop an understanding of landlord-tenant litigation principles, including court requirements and possible defenses
  3. Explore the various non-litigation options and strategies that may be available for resolving landlord-tenant disputes
  4. Appreciate the circumstances where other statutes and legal principles may apply
  5. Discuss recent cases and changes in the laws pertaining to the landlord-tenant relationship


John Ivins

Hirschler Fleischer

John’s commercial litigation practice focuses primarily on healthcare and real estate with extensive experience in state and federal courts, administrative proceedings and mediations/arbitrations. John’s practice also includes serving as a hearing officer and mediator and as an adjunct professor of law. Prior to joining the firm, John served as a staff judicial law clerk for the Supreme Court of Virginia.


John routinely represents hospitals and health systems, advising various committees, hospital staff and MECs/governing boards on:

  • Peer review, credentialing, and bylaw compliance;
  • Fair Hearings/administrative proceedings pertaining to physician privileges/employment disputes;
  • Compliance reviews/audits, regulatory appeals and related litigation;
  • DMAS audits/administrative hearings; and
  • HIPAA compliance, NPDB requirements, contracts/business associate agreements and contract disputes, and a variety of risk management issues including OSHA.

John’s Fair Hearing experience includes serving as counsel to various hospitals and their MECs, serving as counsel to the Fair Hearing Panel and serving as a Hearing Officer. John is also on the American Health Lawyers Association panel of neutrals as both a mediator and hearing officer.

In addition to hospitals and health systems, John represents medical practices, physicians and other healthcare professionals on a wide variety of matters, including physician office operations, HIPAA compliance, contracts and contract/employment disputes. 

He also represents physicians and other healthcare professionals in licensure and related administrative proceedings before various regulatory Boards.

John also represents manufacturers in the healthcare field in various types of product liability litigation. 

Real Estate

John’s real estate practice focuses upon a variety of leasing and related matters, representing regional and national shopping center/mall owners/developers, hospitals and health systems, long-term care facilities and national owners/developers of multi-family housing. With his extensive knowledge of the laws pertaining to landlord-tenant relationships, Stark and Anti-Kickback, creditor rights and bankruptcy, John is called upon to handle a variety of litigation matters and to assist in the development of non-litigation dispute resolution strategies. 

Representative Experience

Healthcare Litigation/Regulatory Matters

  • Representation of various hospitals and health systems in Fair Hearings and related administrative/litigation matters. 
  • Serving as a Hearing Officer and counsel to the Hearing Panel in Fair Hearings.
  • Counsel to hospital executive staff and committees on a variety of operational, management, and physician privilege/employment issues. Examples include:
  • Addressing issues arising during the credentialing process.
  • Handling matters arising following precautionary and other physician suspensions/investigations.
  • Preparing behavioral contracts relative to disruptive physicians.
  • Providing guidance as to bylaw compliance, NPDB reporting requirements, HIPAA compliance, responses to medical records subpoenas, physician contracting, resolving physician disputes/employment issues.
  • Representation of hospitals, health systems and other healthcare providers in internal investigations, compliance audits and related appeals/litigation. In one particular case, a challenge to the particular audit methodology employed by the governmental agency resulted in the withdrawal of a multimillion dollar assessment.

Real Estate/Landlord/Tenant Matters

  • Representation of regional and national mall and shopping center developers and owners in hundreds of tenant disputes as well as slip and fall cases. In one particular suit arising out of a tenant’s default and a subsequent suit filed by the tenant challenging the owner’s sale of tenant’s restaurant furniture and equipment, a jury returned a verdict in favor of the owner following only 10 minutes of deliberation. 
  • Representation of national apartment owners and developers in hundreds of tenant disputes as well as slip and fall cases.
  • Representation of hospitals, health systems and long-term care facilities in real estate/tenant litigation.
  • Representation of a locality following its decision to deny a particular subdivision request. The locality’s decision was upheld following a six-month long trial.

Product Liability

  • Representation of manufacturers in various types of product liability litigation including prosthetic devices, asbestos, seat belts, swimming pools and food. Many of these cases arose in various federal courts and concluded with favorable summary judgment dismissals.


Tom H.

Best presentation I've seen this CLE cycle. Knowledgable speaker, smooth delivery, and covered pretty much all areas of landlord/tenant law from both the plaintiff's and defendant's perspective.

Andrew T.

Excellent presenter.

Kevin M.

Excellent presentation!

Philip C.

Very knowledgeable speaker!

James B.

Good course content and materials.

Antoine M.

Good refresher on Virginia landlord tenant law

Paul O.

he did a nice job. Nice manner.

christopher r.

Terrific presentation of complex area.

Bruce P.

Good program. With all the changes to L-T law in 2017, it could have used another hour.

Joshua G.

Perfect discussion that hit the major amendments to a critical statute in my practice area!

Frank E.

I really like these kind of refresher programs -- narrow topic coverage perfect for an hour

TeriMichelle J.

Great course with useful substantive information for practitioner

Bruce C.

appreciate updates on residential code sections, one of which would have been an embarrassment not to know and which I had missed.

Justin L.

Great job, John!

Jo M.

Able summary of changes in landlord-tenant law in Virginia, and written materials are very helpful.

Carla B.

Best CLE I've taken in a long time! Thank you.

Load More


$ 59 Real Estate and Litigation In Stock


Get Unlimited Access to Lawline Courses

Unlimited CLE Subscription gives you access to take almost any course from our catalog and earn as much CLE credit as you need.